CASINO v RUSTON - DAY ONE AFTERNOON SESSION -WHEELER, EVERDING

Monday May 17, 2010 1:30 pm courtroom 2A Judge Fred Cuthbertson

Please note:No written or audio recording available. Transcript only on appeal. I have done my best but hard to keep up so post may not contain all testimony/arguments but I believe I have captured major points of interest.

This takes a lot of time be patient. Judge's decision may come before I can finish testimony. Judge very precise on issues both sides. Each says they have the law on their side but Judge Cuthbertson makes the final determination.

Attorneys:
Joan Mell for plaintiff Steve Fabre. (m)
David Britton for defendant Town of Ruston. (b)

RE ADJOURN
Judge- to attorneys take a break between question and answer. Humorous holds hands in front of mouth.
Britton (b)- Council Person Albertson?
Judge- Will take Dan Albertson out of order.
WITNESS Kim Wheeler, former Police Chief of Ruston and former Mayor of Ruston.
k- Lived in Ruston nine years.
k- Had training in 1988 became Police Chief in 1990.
k- Mayor of Ruston 2002 to 2005.
k- 2005 still active applied for vacancy in mayor's office.
k- Up until last year aware of budget. Previously worked on budget.
k- As Mayor all reserves exhausted. Down to general fund access money.
k- When I left better off than ever before.
k- When I left law enforcement budget around $280 to $300 thousand dollars.
k- Gave up when they tried to burn through money, frivolous lawsuits ...
Judge- Strike last comment.
m- Mr. Fabre what was his intent on gambling?
k- Council thought it would be beneficial, help business area.
m- Mr Fabre as to taxation?
k- Negotiated plan for graduated tax based on revenue generated. Both do well or he pays minimum.
m- Ordinance 1132 for Social card games. Made graduated rates more efficient?
k- Yes, greater benefit to town if greater volume.
m- Initial category zero percent up to seventy thousand dollars.
k- Seventy thousand leaves no net income point to begin taxation.
m- Tax profit generated revenue for town, benefit to town? Was he only taxpayer for this tax?
k- Yes for this tax.
m- After negotiations with owner and council was Mr. Fabre relying on that graduated rate to do business in Ruston?
k- Yes, in best interest of both else not keeping business open we get nothing.
m- Was graduated tax temporary?
k- No. Graduated rate was for years to come.
m- Revenue to affect tax enforcement requirements nothing. Has local knowledge of budget. Prior business was heavy metal. Card room tax needed none.
m- Things changed in 2008.
m- Ability of Ruston to tax based on limit of enforcement.
m- Was there more tax raised than needed?
k- Yes.
m- Any changes in law enforcement since gambling?
k- No change in activity for 15 years.
m- More tax needed to enforce gambling act?
k- No. Mr. Fabre complied with taxes.
m- Did you attend July 7 hearing?
k- Don't know. Went to council after tax increase was of no benefit to Ruston.
m- Benefits decreased markedly?
k- Yes
CROSS EXAMINATION
David Britton (b) You applied for mayor when Hopkins appointed. What other meetings have you attended?
k- Don't know haven't kept calendar.
b- Wasn't town running half million dollar deficit? Wasn't revenue less than expenses?
k- No. Had 4 to 5 million in bank. Were putting money back into funds.
b- Revenue exceeded expenses?
k- Yes we had balanced budget.
b- Testified direct that Mr. Fabre made profit?
k- Excess of 70 thousand gross revenue he paid taxes.
b- Did you tell Mr. Fabre graduated tax rate was in perpetuity?
k- No not in perpetuity.
m- Card room games only not overall business.
k- Yes.
WITNESS Sally Everding, Ruston Codifier.
m- Live down the alley from the PDC&Casino?
Sally s- Drive down here to our driveway (pointing at picture of PDC&C).
b- Objection. Lived not enjoyed your neighborhood?
Judge- overruled.
s- Had objection to light in my bedroom window.
m- background in records, hired to codify records? Jane Bradley asked you?
s- Council yes.
m- Your husband was Mayor for ten days? Records had not been codifying for years?
s- Did some.
m- You have MBA from Stanford?
s- Yes.
m- You had many interests Ruston Connection?
s- Yes.
b- Objection.
Judge- overruled.
m- What is Ruston Connection?
s- Several friends and I worked on newsletter, not advocacy.
m- One article said gambling taxes weren't high enough?
s- Candidate said taxes were lowest in Pierce County.
m Plaintiff exhibit 55. Handed to Sally "This is article you wrote?"
s- I didn't write article Virginia was editor.
m- Your name is at end of article.
s- I posted on website.
m- Information was taken from News Tribune article?
s- There was error. I was not editor at time.
m- Ruston Connection had litigation with Steve Fabre?
s- Aware of it not involved. Virginia editor, Jane Hunt printed.
m- You codified Gambling Tax Ordinance? Plaintiff exhibit 41 Gambling Tax Ordinance.
m- Was that article you codified?
s- She sent me copy.
m- You had minutes?
s- Pl exh 31 document you had. Bradley Huson signed minutes.
Judge- 55 objected to parties. Admit 55 Pl Exh over objections. 41 and 39 admitted.
m- Did you codify, add July 7th date?
m- What if ordinance didn't have effective date?
s- I used date passed.
m- You just picked a date?
b- Objection.
CROSS EXAMINATION
David Britton - no questions.
Step down.
Judge- Deferring to Dan Albertson.
DAN ALBERTSON - former Ruston council member.

TO BE CONTINUED. GETTING LATE. WILL DO EACH WITNESS LEFT AS SEPARATE POST: Dan Albertson, Jane Hunt, Steve Fabre, Bradley Huson. Then each attorney summation.
-30-